I get it
I work with AI tools every day. My (extremely well trained) mate Claude gets plenty of use, and I'd be slower without him.
So I completely understand why a client recently tried to run a contract negotiation that way, without me helping out. The tools are good now. They will draft, compare and explain in seconds. Compared with staring at a mark-up and hoping for the best, that is a huge increase in what you can get done.
There is nothing silly about reaching for that help. I've done the same with SEO, after a few failed attempts to get teams to do it for me. Plenty of capable people are doing the same thing.
A lesson learned
I came into it after some of the drafts had already gone back and forth a few times.
So some of the drafting needed to be unwound and put back together again. Points that had already been agreed with the other side needed prying out of their hands, and I had to be a bit firm about it.
We recovered some of the ground. We didn't recover all of it.
AI hadn't gone rogue. It just didn't know the client, or how people think, or that a "leave that, it's fine" approach to negotiation was not a clear, well informed instruction. It did a great job, based on what it was told.
That is the bit that is easy to miss.
AI doesn't remember the meeting, or how people reacted. It doesn't know that the way one person said something meant we could probably hold one point if we gave a little on another. Unless you tell it carefully every time, or train it to handle the things that don't need human experience, it will work to rules.
It doesn't feel the difference between a point you can live with and a point you cannot. A fluent, confident answer isn't the same as knowing the parties, the history of the deal and how the other side will react.
What AI is good at
This is not an argument against using it. It's amazing.
Used simply, it gets you off the ground. Used well, it can give you a first draft when you would otherwise have nothing to say. Trained well, it can cut through a complex agreement and give you all the advice you need to hurt yourself.
It catches small issues much better than we would: things changed on the quiet, or the fact you're working from an old draft. It will put a dense clause into plain English so you can see what you are being asked to accept.
I use it that way myself, and I layer a trained set of skills and bots on top so it does what I would want it to.
Even with the best systems, your work still needs a person. It is your work. If you don't know how to respond in detail, what to leave out as well as what to pull in, you need to get from 60 to 80% right to 90 to 100%. That gap can be the difference between a well negotiated insurance or liability clause and a poor one.
If I didn't train them, this is how I would use AI
A simple habit covers most of this.
- Use the tool to get started. Ask it for a first pass, a list of issues or a comparison against the last agreed version.
- Tell it the commercial context, including what is already settled and must not be reopened.
- Read the output as a draft and an explanation, not as a reply. Check it against the last agreed position before anything goes back to the other side.
- If a point has already been won, be wary of any rewrite that makes it "fairer" or "clearer" without being asked to.
Check it yourself. If it doesn't make sense, it might just not make sense.
Getting to 90 to 100%
This is ordinary commercial work, and it is exactly the sort of thing I sit alongside clients to do. I'm comfortable with AI, and I have experience in all the work I do.
So I've trained my AI. I have skills (around 20 now), bots and routines. I also have a small AI at home which is being set up to review files and do admin for me. More on that in another blog.
A really well trained, coded and tested set of skills, bots and routines, looped, maintained and looked after while it works, will push you to 80 to 90%.
So how does this compare with what you used to pay for? I can now get you to a higher rate of success, incredibly quickly. Two-hour turnarounds for redrafts. One hour for due diligence reviews (excluding set-up, to be fair, which can take hours). One-click bundle creation. Daily updates and briefings.
That means my time is spent on clients: what they want, how they work, customer care, thinking around their needs, selling back in, marketing and BD.
Clients see a significant reduction in cost, along with better customer service. I'm still getting them to 90 to 100%, as I always did. It's just better.
This is general commentary, not advice on a particular contract or set of tools. Silva is a legal advisory and AI consultancy, not a law firm. Any support depends on the agreed scope and what we can and cannot help with.
Frequently asked questions
Should I use AI in a contract negotiation?
Yes, as a way to get started. It is excellent for first drafts, comparisons and plain English explanations. Have someone who knows the deal review the output before it goes to the other side.
Why can AI undo points that were already agreed?
It doesn't automatically know the history of the negotiation. Unless you tell it what is settled, a helpful rewrite can put agreed points back into play.
Do I still need a person involved?
For anything that will go back to the other side, yes. The tool gets you moving. A person who understands the commercial context should steer it.
Happy to have a chat
If this is on your desk at the moment, I'm happy to have a chat if useful. hello@silvalex.co.uk